Planning journals join hands to build academic integrity
浏览次数: 448次 Release time: 2019/12/5 10 : 41 : 49Views : 448
share to:


From November 22nd to 23rd, the "2019 China Urban Planning Society Editing and Publishing Annual Meeting" was successfully held in Beijing. The annual conference was hosted by the China Urban Planning Society's Editorial and Publication Working Committee (hereinafter referred to as the “Editorial Committee”), and organized by the Editorial Department of “Beijing Planning and Construction” and Beijing Urban Planning and Design Institute. A total of 31 member journals participated.


At the meeting, the representatives of the journal units unanimously adopted the "Procedures for Building Academic Integrity." The procedure is divided into five parts, the following are the details.

Rules for Building Academic Integrity

I. Principles Respect the scientific and technological achievements of scientific and technological workers, follow the principles of active guidance, prevention first, and punish the future in good faith. Promote a good atmosphere of academic research and publication of results in the field of planning, and promote a sound academic environment.
2. The journals of the member of the editorial board work in concert to take advantage of the media, strengthen the publicity of scientific research integrity, popularize relevant knowledge, and prevent academic misconduct. Give full play to the linkage mechanism of journals, in the investigation and punishment of academic misconduct, achieve information exchange, mutual assistance in investigation, and mutual recognition of results.
Third, academic integrity publicity Member journals do a good job of their own academic integrity construction, take the lead to maintain a good academic atmosphere. Use their own media resources to promote academic integrity related knowledge to scientific researchers in a combination of online promotion and offline activities.
4. Academic misconduct The definition of academic misconduct is implemented in accordance with relevant national laws and regulations. Member journals should communicate with each other, conduct collaborative investigations, handle the journals independently, and report the results.
The following treatments are recommended based on the severity of the plot:
1. Remind the authors to revise the academic misconduct in unpublished articles; for severe academic misconduct, take a rejection process and remind the author of academic misconduct;
2. For academic misconduct in articles that have been formally published, authors are required to correct academic misconduct by themselves and eliminate adverse effects;
3. For articles with serious academic misconduct, adopt the method of revoking the articles, ordering the author to apologize publicly to eliminate the adverse effects, and notify the author's unit or school;
4. Inform authors of academic misconduct authors' journals in a “friendly way”;
5. Authors with deliberate serious academic misconduct are included in the unified "warning list" of the editorial board.
V. Other explanations Academic misconduct shall be investigated and determined by each member unit to determine the processing method, and the decision to deal with the journal shall be final. All member units shall strictly define the scope of protection of intellectual property rights in accordance with the law, fully respect the labor achievements of scientific research personnel, and adopt a rigorous and serious attitude to identify relevant facts and make reasonable decisions.

Joint Response Journal (in order of the first stroke of the journal title)

"People and Cities", "Human Geography", "Human Living", "Shanghai Urban Planning", "Small Town Construction", "Shandong Urban Planning", "Mountain Urban and Rural Planning", "Yunnan Urban Planning", "Regional and Urban Economy", "China's Famous Cities", "China" Gardens, Landscape Architecture, Phoenix City, Beijing Planning and Construction, Journal of Western Habitat Environment, Chengdu Planning, Jiangsu Urban Planning, Modern Urban Studies, Planner, Planning Review, Planner "Planning Zhengzhou", "International Urban Planning", "Architecture Journal", "Urban and Rural Planning", "Urban and Rural Construction", "City", "Urban and Regional Planning Research", "City China", "Urban Development", "Urban Transport", "Urban Issues", "Cities Observation, "Urban Planning", "Urban Planning", "Urban Planning Journal", "Urban Planning Informatization", "Urban Planning Newsletter", "Urban Space Design", "Urban Information", "Southern Architecture", "Langfang Planning Research"
The first half of the morning session was the opening ceremony of the annual meeting. The opening ceremony was chaired by Ma Liangwei, the editor-in-chief of Beijing Planning and Construction, Liu Xingping, deputy director of the Academic Department of the Chinese Academy of Science and Technology, Shi Nan, executive vice-chairman and secretary-general of the China Urban Planning Society, executive editor of the Urban Planning Society, vice-chairman of the society, Beijing Shi Weiliang, president of the Urban Planning and Design Institute and other leaders attended the meeting and delivered speeches.


In his speech, Liu Xingping, deputy director of the Academic Department of the Chinese Association of Science and Technology, pointed out that joint actions such as building academic integrity and resisting academic misconduct are of great significance. As an academic community, the society should play a cohesive consensus, value guidance, positive incentives, adhere to the bottom line and Supervising and restricting, to prevent blind follow-up, blind enlargement and blind politicization. He said: "Although journals are small incisions, the big ecology is behind them. The relationship between authors, editors, and readers is actually closely related to the country's science and technology, economy, society, and culture. At present, the development of journals in China has reached The new stage of collectivization and digitization marks the periodical reform towards the deepwater area. I hope that the Editorial Working Committee of the Chinese Urban Planning Society will take the momentum, adhere to the priority of quality, adhere to the bottom line of integrity, and actively promote the construction of style of study and morality, and promote the spirit of science and scientists Resolutely resist academic misconduct and make positive contributions. "


Shi Nan, executive deputy director and secretary-general of the China Urban Planning Association, and executive editor of Urban Planning, said: "Creating a good academic ecological environment, strengthening the integrity of scientific research, and promoting the building of a study style are important tasks of the society, and are the first work of the editorial and publishing committee. Historical mission. "Shi Nan emphasized that the first point is that the journals of the society and the editorial and publishing committees should effectively combine online media to create a good academic ecological environment, strengthen the construction of scientific research integrity, and promote the construction of academic style; secondly, academic journals should innovate Mechanism to raise planning science popularization work to a new level, so that more people can master planning knowledge; thirdly, scientific and technological journals should fully cooperate with the work of the new competent department, so that discipline construction promotes leading industry work. Sci-tech periodicals should play a role when there is confusion in the industry. Through the construction of the internal system of the Editing and Publishing Working Committee, the construction of scientific integrity and a good style of study in planning disciplines should be promoted. The journals should be used to guide and achieve the improvement and development of planning disciplines.


Vice Chairman of the Society and Dean Shi Weiliang of Beijing Urban Planning and Design Institute introduced in his speech a series of urban planning work carried out after the "Beijing Urban Master Plan (2016-2035)" was approved, among which academic journals are leading the industry , Discipline construction, social consensus and popularization of science popularization. Dean Shi Weiliang also introduced the series of propaganda and exploration conducted by Beijing TV Station, Beijing Planning and Natural Resources Commission and Beijing Urban Planning and Design Institute in the era of all-media. How to participate in social governance and grass-roots work is demonstrated through television programs. Dean Shi said: "Take the opportunity of the 2019 China Urban Planning Society to publish the annual conference, I hope my colleagues in the industry can provide insights to promote better planning in all aspects of Beijing."


Li Lin, the general manager of Urban Planning magazine, read the Code of Academic Integrity on behalf of the editorial board, and the member journals passed the rule with warm applause.
The second half of the morning session was chaired by Wang Jing, deputy director of the editorial department of Shanghai Urban Planning. The meeting invited three experts to give a speech.


Huang Xiaoru, an associate researcher of the Academy of Science and Technology Strategic Consulting of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, introduced the new situation of scientific research integrity construction, and gave a detailed interpretation of "Academic Publishing Specifications-Definition of Academic Misconduct in Periodicals (CY / T174-2019)". Duan Yongchao, Executive Chairman of the Forum on 50 People in the Information Society, described the changes in the age of the digital economy and the globalization of multimedia integration with the title "Rethinking Rethinking the Rethinking of the Digital Age"; Zhao Hongshicong, Director of the Policy and Regulation Division of Beijing Radio and Television Bureau From the perspective of copyright law, it interprets the core content of copyright and common copyright issues in journal management. After the speech, experts also answered questions about academic integrity, copyright, and copyright ownership of the journals of the members. The atmosphere in the venue was very warm.


On the afternoon of the same day, the editorial committee held a working meeting. The meeting was chaired by Zeng Wei, the executive editor of the Journal of the Western Human Settlement and Environment, and Li Lin, the general manager of Urban Planning magazine, made a work report on behalf of the editorial committee. The work report reviewed the work of the editorial committee in 2018-2019. The editorial committee organized a variety of activities in 2019, and formulated a code of conduct for academic integrity of the editorial committee. Member units provide services. The report also proposes work ideas for 2019-2020. It is expected that more journal units will take advantage of the organizational advantages of the editorial board to learn from each other, act in concert, and develop together.
Shi Nan, the chief editor of Urban Planning, shared the case of academic misconduct in the journal at the meeting. The case gave some enlightenment to the committee members of the journals. First, the journals should attach importance to the authorization and signature of fund project papers. Second, the journals should attach importance to academic degrees. The thesis rewrites the signature specifications of small papers; third, to strengthen the internal information communication of the editorial board; fourth, journals should remind authors and authors' units to increase copyright awareness.
Zhou Xuemei, deputy editor-in-chief of "Beijing Planning and Construction", exchanges the characteristics of running journals. She said that "Beijing Planning and Construction" is an "old" journal that has been published for more than 30 years, but after a major revision in 2004, it continued to innovate and strive to stay at the forefront of the industry. Based on the concepts of "multi-content positioning, multi-element structure, cover theme creation, and picture-reading era", the journal pays more attention to the academic, creative, timeliness, and vividness of the journal, forming a unique office of Beijing Planning and Construction. Journal Features.
Li Fang, editor of the Journal of the Western Human Settlement Environment, introduced the "Academic Misconduct Punishment and Prevention Mechanism." The main contents of the mechanism include the definition of academic misconduct, the evaluation work mechanism, behavior determination and reporting procedures, and punishment.
The participating journal units actively spoke and exchanged discussions after listening to the sharing report.
Secretary-General Shi Nan made a concluding speech. He pointed out that the most important thing for journals and magazines is to base themselves on a new era and new needs, to reposition the work of various journals and committee units, to emphasize the spirit of scientists and the building of academic integrity; In the network environment, journals in various professional fields should promptly speak out on disputed topics; each periodical unit should adapt to the changing environment of the competent unit and develop the discipline system; it should clarify the reform of basic laws and policies, and advocate positively against academic misconduct.
At the end of the meeting, the handover ceremony of the annual conference was held. The 2020 annual edition of the China Urban Planning Association's editing and publishing conference was hosted by the Urban Planning Academic Journal.
Source: http://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/2GhbHfSylBeDQv6aZubQRQ

Disclaimer: This website is a non-profit website. Most of the information comes from the recommendations of netizens. If the author or other copyright owner believes your rights are violated, please let us know and we will remove them within 24 hours.